3 Actors Who Should’ve Played Javert in ‘Les Misérables’

Where have Hollywood’s high standards gone? I suppose we’ve been asking that question since about 1936, so maybe by now it’s useless. I suppose I expect better from an Academy Award-winning director bringing a Tony Award-winning musical to the big screen. Les Misérables’ swooping, ultra-zoomed camera work and CGI effects were distracting enough, but the singing of many of the film’s main characters left me wishing for earmuffs after the first sixty minutes.

Adam Lambert succinctly summed up many of my thoughts on the casting problems with this latest iteration of Victor Hugo’s 1862 novel:

“Les Mis: Visually impressive w great Emotional performances. But the score suffered massively with great actors PRETENDING to be singers…it’s an opera. Hollywoods movie musicals treat the singing as the last priority.”

To which Russell Crowe, probably the biggest albatross in the entire production, responded:

“I don’t disagree with Adam,sure it could have been sweetened,Hooper wanted it raw and real,that’s how it is”

I think he was missing the point of Lambert’s message.

My criticisms have nothing to do with “polish”; in fact, I’d much rather have an emotional, real interpretation of a song than something sanitized for the sake of a mass audience. A raw, nuanced and physically subtle performance is one of the few benefits of filming a stage musical rather than seeing it live. This isn’t a question of performances being “sweetened”–rather, it’s a question of casting competent, if not professional, singers in the lead roles rather than actors who’d be much better in a non-musical version of the story.

Russell Crowe may be passable as a rock singer, but as Javert, he is a disaster: absolutely no vibrato, straining in both the upper and lower registers, and a general glazed look about the eyes starting in the first verse of every number. (Philip Quast, where art thou?)

So, Tom Hooper, here’s some casting advice: a list of three actors I think would have been better as Inspector Javert. Remember that many actors can play fierceness and obsession, but few actors can do that and also sing it convincingly.

3. John Travolta

john-travoltaTravolta’s mainly known for comedic rather than dramatic singing, but I think he could have pulled this role off. He’s already proven his singing ability in Grease and Hairspray, and though they were less than serious roles, his repeat stints as action movie villains would lend an element of menace to his interpretation.

 

 

2. Johnny Depp

johnny-deppIs there any doubt Depp could have been the quirkiest, darkest Javert in history? (Not to mention the best-looking.) I think he would have brought a nuance to the role that would have emphasized the character’s inner vulnerability and the root of his obsession better than the stage musical has ever been able to. He did a decent job of singing the role of the demon barber in Sweeney Todd, so we know he’s got the villain chops.

 

 

1. Christopher Lee

christopher-leeThough he’s my top pick, some might say Sir Christopher would be a bit too old for this part, but that’s what makeup artists are for. Villainy is in this man’s blood, so to speak. Vengeance, bloodlust, dogged pursuit…it’s all there and then some. His concept album Charlemagne proves that he’s got the voice, and his deep, throaty pipes would add some nice dimension to Javert’s songs.

This entry was posted in Cultural musings and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to 3 Actors Who Should’ve Played Javert in ‘Les Misérables’

  1. Hannah says:

    I can’t agree with John Travolta. Whether he could act it or not, is not the problem for me; I just wouldn’t be able to take him seriously on any level. I think Russell Crowe at least looked the part, if not performed it well. Depp would have made a great Javert though, I never thought of him! He doesn’t have a very operatic voice, but its still great. I’ve never heard Lee sing, but its not hard to believe he’d be better than Crowe. Great article!

  2. Octavian Sarbu says:

    Crowe pulled it off very good… it’s not all about the singing…

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s